Roof Bros Restoration Logo

Insurance Claim Help

Roof Bros Restoration Logo

Insurance Claim Help

Insurance Claim Help

Understanding Ordinance, Law & Building Code Upgrade Coverage

After a storm or property loss, repairing a home or commercial building often involves more than simply replacing what was damaged. In many cases, current building codes, municipal requirements, or updated installation standards can increase the scope and cost of repairs during the restoration process.

Ordinance & Law coverage — sometimes referred to as Building Code Upgrade Coverage — is generally intended to help address certain costs associated with bringing damaged property into compliance with applicable building requirements at the time repairs are performed. Common examples can include upgraded roofing components, ventilation requirements, flashing details, ice and water barrier installation, fastening standards, or other code-required improvements that may not have been part of the original construction.

Modern building codes and manufacturer installation specifications exist to improve structural integrity, weather resistance, occupant safety, and long-term performance. Proper code enforcement and compliant installation practices can play a significant role in reducing future storm damage and improving the resilience of homes and commercial structures.

However, coverage for code-related upgrades can vary significantly depending on the policy language, local jurisdiction requirements, age of the structure, and the specific facts of the loss. Certain requirements imposed by private HOA bylaws, architectural committees, or neighborhood covenants may also be evaluated differently than government-adopted building codes.

At Roof Bros Restoration, we help identify visible storm-related damage, document potential code-related considerations, and prepare detailed repair scopes designed to support the restoration process. Final coverage determinations, policy interpretation, and claim decisions remain the responsibility of the insurance carrier based on the applicable policy terms and governing regulations.

Understanding “Matching” in Insurance Claims

One of the most common disputes in property insurance claims involves “matching” — especially after hail or wind damage to roofing or siding. Many homeowners’ policies state that damaged materials will be repaired or replaced with materials of “like kind and quality” or “similar materials.” The challenge arises when the original products have been discontinued or weathered over time, making an exact match difficult or impossible.

For example, if only one slope of a roof or one section of siding is damaged, replacing only the affected area may leave the home with noticeable color or texture differences. In some states, insurance regulations require repairs to result in a “reasonably uniform appearance,” while in others, the outcome depends heavily on the policy language and the specific facts of the loss.

Matching concerns are most commonly associated with Replacement Cost Value (RCV) policies, which generally pay to replace damaged property without deducting for depreciation. In contrast, Actual Cash Value (ACV) policies typically account for depreciation and may provide more limited repair allowances.

Several courts across the country have addressed matching disputes involving discontinued shingles and siding. Some rulings have recognized that replacing only part of a roof or exterior may not restore the property’s prior appearance, while others have allowed partial repairs where a reasonably comparable appearance could still be achieved.

Because matching requirements vary by state, policy language, product availability, and local regulations, every claim should be evaluated individually. At Roof Bros Restoration, we help document storm-related damage, identify discontinued materials when applicable, and provide detailed repair scopes to assist homeowners throughout the restoration process.

This article is for informational purposes only and is not legal or insurance coverage advice.

Understanding the Insurance Appraisal Process

Many property insurance policies include an appraisal clause designed to help resolve disagreements over the amount of a covered loss. Appraisal is commonly used when the homeowner and insurance carrier agree that damage exists, but disagree on the scope of repairs or the value of the loss.

In most situations, appraisal becomes an option only after both sides have had a reasonable opportunity to inspect the property, exchange documentation, and evaluate the claim. Courts in multiple states have generally held that appraisal is intended for disputes involving the amount of loss, not broader coverage disputes or questions about whether damage is covered under the policy.

The appraisal process typically involves each party selecting an independent appraiser. Those appraisers then work to reach an agreement on the value of the loss. If they cannot agree, an impartial umpire may be selected to help resolve the differences. Depending on the circumstances, appraisal can sometimes provide a faster and more cost-effective alternative to prolonged disputes.

Appraisal is frequently discussed in larger or more complex property claims involving roofing systems, siding, commercial buildings, condominium associations, or storm-related damage where repair scope and pricing are heavily disputed.

At Roof Bros Restoration, we assist property owners by documenting storm damage, preparing detailed repair estimates, and providing supporting documentation that may help clarify the scope of necessary repairs during the claims process. Because every policy and claim situation is different, homeowners should consult directly with their insurance carrier or qualified professionals regarding questions about coverage, claim rights, or whether appraisal may apply to their specific situation.

We give you options.

You decide what works best for you.

Get a FREE QUOTE

for our services

Get a Free Inspection

Get a Free Inspection

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)
Address(Required)
I would like a quote for:(Required)

People love what we do

  • Brian D.
    Brian D.
    2026-04-22
    Thumbtack

    I had a small job one piece of damaged siding Despite many larger jobs in the area due to a Read More

  • Brin B.
    Brin B.
    2026-04-22
    Thumbtack

    As a first time home owner I ve learned a lot Anything that can go wrong might Especially in the Read More

  • Jessie W.
    Jessie W.
    2026-04-22
    Thumbtack

    I am grateful for the work that Roof Bros did on my home They even helped me navigate the insurance Read More

  • Bonnie Newton
    Bonnie Newton
    2026-04-14
    Google

    Great service. Great experience. Went above and beyond to work with our insurance company to get everything covered/approved.

  • Roof Bros did an absolutely amazing job on my home After storm damage I needed a new roof and siding Read More

  • Curt Calvin
    Curt Calvin
    2025-12-20
    Google

    These guys are great We have had a wonderful experience with Roof Bros Restoration These guys did jobs all down Read More

  • Brenda Clinton
    Brenda Clinton
    2025-11-20
    Google

  • Brin Baitman
    Brin Baitman
    2025-11-20
    Google

    Dan is responsive knowledgeable and organized Ramonne is friendly and extremely knowledgeable They answered all our questions promptly and kept Read More

  • Terry Parsons
    Terry Parsons
    2025-09-20
    Google

    They did a great job on my house. Dan was really polite and listen to me

  • Corrie Burtch
    Corrie Burtch
    2025-09-20
    Google

    Dan Knopp and Roof Brothers were exceptional in their customer service and interface with our insurance company Their crew worked Read More

  • Kelsey Brune
    Kelsey Brune
    2025-09-20
    Google

    Worked with Jon to initiate the inspection process Ramonne was very helpful walking me through the necessary steps for the Read More

  • Jeff Brandhorst
    Jeff Brandhorst
    2025-04-20
    Google

    Good work , great communication throughout

  • Frank Herndon
    Frank Herndon
    2025-04-20
    Google

    Roof Bros Restoration proved to me to be professional efficient and very informative They are courteous and easy to communicate Read More

  • Carl
    Carl
    2025-04-20
    Google

    Super professional from the very start They do beautiful work using the best products Our home owner insurance adjuster said Read More

  • Gina Hotze
    Gina Hotze
    2025-04-20
    Google

    Very happy with the work that was provided on our home after the Memorial Day hailstorm of Dan was great Read More

  • Harland Foster
    Harland Foster
    2024-04-20
    Google

  • Virginia Lavely
    Virginia Lavely
    2024-04-20
    Google

    Really enjoyed dealing with Dan and his crew They were very professional and did an amazing job I would highly Read More

  • Gina Pingleton
    Gina Pingleton
    2024-04-20
    Google

    We have never dealt with such a great company They went out of their way to get the job done Read More

  • Charlie Beach
    Charlie Beach
    2024-04-20
    Google

    Great experience working with Dan and Rammone on our insurance replacement hail damaged roof Prompt courteous professional Roof looks great Read More

  • This company is awesome Very impressed by how fast the job was done Dan was most helpful and knowledgeable in Read More

  • JulieP
    JulieP
    2024-04-20
    Google

    Above and beyond on every level Excellent customer service and care flexible to our schedule Met to review options and Read More

  • Kevin McDaniel
    Kevin McDaniel
    2024-04-20
    Google

    Highly recommend Roof Bros Restoration Overall they cared as much about my roof house as I do They have a Read More

  • Sharon J.
    Sharon J.
    2023-10-29
    Thumbtack

    Details: Partial roof replacement • Roof is cracked or damaged • One story • Asphalt shingles • Maybe, insurance claim pending • Home

  • Joanna l.
    Joanna l.
    2023-10-02
    Thumbtack

    Details: Full roof replacement • Roof is leaking or has water damage • Roof lifespan is over • One story • Asphalt shingles • Home

  • Melvin J.
    Melvin J.
    2023-09-17
    Thumbtack

    Details: Replace old gutters • Less than 1,000 sq ft • Single-level building • Residential • I would like to discuss with the professional

  • Sam T.
    Sam T.
    2023-08-21
    Thumbtack

    Roof Bros went above and beyond on my project They were very responsive and listened to my requested and honored Read More

  • Ron P.
    Ron P.
    2023-08-05
    Thumbtack

    I would recommend Roof Bros Restoration to anyone needing quality work done I was completely satisfied with the work on Read More

  • Nicole D.
    Nicole D.
    2023-04-25
    Thumbtack

    I definitely recommend this company based on the professionalism and prompt customer service I received. Thank you Ramonne!

  • Jill Alexander
    Jill Alexander
    2023-04-20
    Google

    Love the way our new roof looks. Dan and his crew were wonderful to work with.

  • My sister recommended Roof Bros Restoration to me and I m so glad She uses them for all of her Read More

  • Robert B
    Robert B
    2023-04-20
    Google

    Dan was extremely professional worked around our busy schedules for meeting times to go over estimates and perform walkthroughs He Read More

  • hallie culver
    hallie culver
    2023-04-20
    Google

    We had a local company replace our roof in early That company did a poor job of properly installing our Read More

  • C Haas
    C Haas
    2023-04-20
    Google

    My roof is a very steep pitched and high structure with a great amount of detail They did an excellent Read More

  • Jessie W.
    Jessie W.
    2023-04-06
    Thumbtack

    I had a wonderful experience with Ramonne and Roof Bros Restoration Friendly Knowledgeable and Customer-Oriented I appreciate their ability to Read More

  • Daniel C.
    Daniel C.
    2023-01-07
    Thumbtack

    The team completed a full roof and gutter replacement as part of an insurance claim The staff assisted with the Read More

  • chazharvey19
    chazharvey19
    2022-04-20
    Google

    Excellent roofing company! Highly recommended to get the job done right!

  • Leslie Hart
    Leslie Hart
    2022-04-20
    Google

    I had a roof leak out of the blue and Dan came out right away to put up a temporary Read More

  • Matthew Nichols
    Matthew Nichols
    2022-04-20
    Google

    They were nothing but professional Honest and upfront about everything and helped navigate the insurance company questions and the entire Read More

  • George Knopp
    George Knopp
    2022-04-20
    Google

    They are very knowledgeable and professional. Good attention to details.

  • Aleem Johnson
    Aleem Johnson
    2022-04-20
    Google

    Always on time, and very courteous! Very helpful, understanding, and thorough.

  • Danielle Will
    Danielle Will
    2022-04-20
    Google

    These guys were fantastic and showed so much empathy to us first time homeowners Our first storm was horrible and Read More

  • Lisa Laidley
    Lisa Laidley
    2022-04-20
    Google

    Roof Bros Restoration did a very professional and spot on job recently on our roof! We highly recommend them!

  • Eric W.
    Eric W.
    2022-04-09
    Thumbtack

    These guys really helped me out with my insurance claim I was originally denied for having hail damage They offered Read More

  • Judi E.
    Judi E.
    2021-08-19
    Thumbtack

    Very professional and Business like.They are Accurate and most certainly take pride in their work The best I've seen!

  • Nick W.
    Nick W.
    2021-08-19
    Thumbtack

    I ve never delt with an insurance claim before but roof bros explained everything before hand and made sure to Read More

  • Megan Kotlar
    Megan Kotlar
    2021-07-29
    Facebook

    Amazing service Professionally managed Always willing to help people in need after big storms Definitely check them out for all Read More

  • Jeff Ward
    Jeff Ward
    2021-07-29
    Facebook

    A true professional and a pleasure to deal with I highly recommend Roof Bros Restoration for any and every roofing Read More

  • Skyyler Crask
    Skyyler Crask
    2021-07-29
    Facebook

    All around great experience every time. Would definitely recommend 10/10!

  • Marc Laidley
    Marc Laidley
    2021-07-29
    Facebook

    Roof Bros Restoration gave us a new roof recently and we couldn t be more impressed with their professional services Read More

  • Martin Bates
    Martin Bates
    2021-07-29
    Facebook

    If you need the job done right the first time, these are your guys!!

  • Geoff Duval
    Geoff Duval
    2021-07-29
    Facebook

    Had such a great experience with this company from start to finish The entire process was so simple and everyone Read More

  • Lisa Dee
    Lisa Dee
    2021-07-29
    Facebook

    Roof Bros did a great job on our roof this past month They were very accurate and got everything covered Read More

  • Walter Brown
    Walter Brown
    2021-07-29
    Facebook

    They are reliable and trust worthy which is huge for me in todays market and a side from that the Read More

  • Edward Jones
    Edward Jones
    2021-08-25
    Google

    Didn’t take long at all … Great Job

Scroll to Top
Skip to content